top of page

Two things that make healthy habits easier

Writer: Dr John Briffa
Dr John Briffa
2 days ago
3 min read

While I support the idea of people looking after themselves with healthy behaviours, I am somewhat resistant to the idea of people living like Trappist monks. Part of the reason for this is research suggesting that things forbidden to us tend to grab our attention and stick in our minds [1].


Interestingly, when something is forbidden to people more generally, this effect seems to diminish. So, someone who is trying not to drink alcohol may find themselves having intrusive thoughts about it. However, if that person were to live in a country in which alcohol was prohibited, not being ‘allowed’ to drink might pose less of a challenge.


These research findings remind me of a common piece of advice I give around behaviours relating to ‘rules': being vague about goals or intentions is less helpful than being specific. So, for example, saying ‘I should drink less’ is less compelling than ‘I do not drink at home during the working week’. The second example is essentially a rule. I’ve found that specific, self-applied rules tend to work well for people, and research on ‘implementation intentions’ (specific plans for when, where and how we will act) supports this [2].


Rules give some structure and consistency around a behaviour, and they also tend to take decision-making out of the process. In effect, the decision is made ahead of time. This reduces the risk of what is sometimes termed ‘decision fatigue’: a tendency for people to opt for the ‘easier’ choice after making many decisions. With a rule, there is really nothing to decide.


What suits most people, I’ve found, is to make choices that support them on autopilot, with occasional, controlled diversions. It’s one reason why I generally advise that ‘it’s what we do most of the time, not some of the time, that’s most important’. For example, even if someone eats a diet based on natural, unprocessed foods, there may still be a place for occasional bread, pasta or pizza.


At the same time, I believe it helps to take an approach that makes it easy to ‘do the right thing’.


One thing that tends to work well here is avoiding getting very hungry, because when we do, there’s often a tendency to crave foods such as chocolate, cake, and biscuits. Resisting such cravings can take considerable willpower. You may have heard the idea that willpower is like a muscle: once exercised, it is weaker for some time afterwards.


This idea was supported by research in which people given a sugary drink between two tests of self-control did better on the second test than those given an artificially sweetened drink. This suggested that sugar might ‘refuel’ willpower [3].


Hunger also has the potential to impact mood. In one study that tracked people’s feelings through the day, greater hunger was associated with more anger and irritability [4]. Eating in a way that keeps hunger at bay (for example, regular meals containing protein and fibre, and healthy snacks where needed) can, I think, go a long way towards preventing cravings for less healthy foods. It also means we need to rely less on willpower in the first place.


I wrote about the value of ‘healthy snacking’ a couple of weeks ago. One benefit is that it helps stop us getting overly hungry and ‘hangry’. Among other things, managing appetite helps keep irrational thoughts and behaviours at bay.


Again, my experience is that a sustainable approach for most people is a solid foundation with occasional excursions. Rules, and avoiding a rampant appetite, usually help a lot.


References:


1. Truong G, et al. An unforgettable apple: memory and attention for forbidden objects. Cogn Affect Behav Neurosci. 2013;13(4):803–813.


2. Gollwitzer PM, Sheeran P. Implementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis of effects and processes. Adv Exp Soc Psychol. 2006;38:69–119.


3. Gailliot MT, Baumeister RF, DeWall CN, et al. Self-control relies on glucose as a limited energy source: willpower is more than a metaphor. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2007;92(2):325–336.


4. Swami V, Hochstöger S, Kargl E, Stieger S. Hangry in the field: an experience sampling study on the impact of hunger on anger, irritability, and affect. PLoS One. 2022;17(7):e0269629.

 
 
bottom of page