top of page

Despite its unhealthy reputation, snacking can be good for both the body and brain

Writer: Dr John Briffa
Dr John Briffa
Nov 4
3 min read


For decades, weight loss theory was based on ‘the calorie principle’. Basically, the idea is that if we consume fewer calories than we burn through metabolism and activity, we lose weight. This is where the idea that losing weight is simply a matter of ‘eating less or exercising more’ comes from. 


While the calorie principle has a core truth, I don’t advise focusing on it for those who want to lose excess fat successfully and sustainably.


One of my major qualms is that many people will interpret being hungry as a sure sign they are in a caloric deficit. Even if this were true, I’d argue that allowing oneself to endure hunger is not necessarily the best way.


Firstly, some maths…


Let’s imagine someone burns about 2,400 calories a day, which equates to about 200 calories per hour.


Leaving fluid balance aside, if no food is eaten for an hour, then that 200-calorie deficit equates to about 22 grams of fat – assuming that only fat is burnt during this time. That’s the equivalent of about two tablespoons of butter. Better than nothing, but the weight is not exactly falling off. 


Against this, some real risks come with ‘going hungry’. 


• Uncontrolled eating 

Once someone's appetite runs riot, it typically leads to far-from-ideal choices about what they eat, and how much. Problems tend to surface in the evening, with a tendency to overeat at dinner and perhaps graze late into the night.


• A 'need' for alcohol

Most alcoholic drinks raise blood sugar levels quite quickly, and some people unwittingly use alcohol as a ‘surrogate food’ when they're hungry. In my experience, many people who feel they ‘need a drink’ at the end of the day are not really crying out for alcohol but for sugar.


• Bad mood

You may be familiar with the term ‘hangry’ – the irritable, intolerant state some of us slip into when we've gone too long without food. There seems to be a genuine biochemical basis for this. When blood sugar levels drop, the body turns on the stress response, and the brain may ramp up production of ‘glutamate’, a chemical messenger implicated in anxiety.


• Lower willpower and self-control

Willpower is what we use to do the right thing, rather than the easier thing: sticking with a demanding task instead of checking email, taking some exercise at the end of a long day, or resisting dessert. Evidence suggests that when blood sugar levels dip, willpower ebbs away [1]. In short, undue hunger makes almost everything harder and can derail even the noblest of intentions.


• Distraction

Hunger is distracting. When work requires our focus, ‘needing to eat’ can easily pull our attention away.


The right snack, at the right time

It's fine to get somewhat hungry from time to time. The aim is to avoid hunger that harms our focus, mood and eating habits. Here, snacking can be hugely helpful. Snacking doesn't enjoy a particularly healthy reputation, but the issue is not snacking itself – it's what we snack on.


While fruit is often touted as the ideal snack, I'm not such a fan. The main job of a snack is to sate the appetite, ideally for an extended period, and for most people, most of the time, fruit doesn't do this well. Foods rich in protein and/or fat tend to be much more effective.


My go-to recommendation is nuts. Many people assume they're fattening, yet research shows those who eat nuts regularly generally weigh less than those who don't, and that adding nuts to the diet doesn't tend to cause weight gain [2]. The most likely reason is that nuts are very good at satisfying the appetite, so we naturally eat less of other foods. Other good options include seeds, olives, biltong, cold meats, cold seafood, hard-boiled eggs and nut butter. 


One practical tip: keep your snacks accessible but invisible. A closed drawer at your desk or a pouch in your bag means they're there when you need them, without tempting you when you don't.


A simple rule

If I were to sum up my advice, it would be this: eat regularly enough of the right foods to avoid undue hunger. How often that is varies from person to person, and even from day to day. Get it right, and you're likely to find your energy steadier, your mood brighter, your focus sharper and healthy eating altogether easier.


References:


1. Gailliot MT, et al. The physiology of willpower: linking blood glucose to self-control. Personality and Social Psychology Review. 2007;11(4):303–27


2. Sabaté J. Nut consumption and body weight. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2003;78(3 Suppl):647S–650S

 
 
bottom of page